Skip to main content

Water vs. Spirit

I may tread on toes with this post, but please bear with me. I want to explore a bit.
"I baptize you with water. But one more powerful than I will come.... He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and with fire." Luke 3:16 NIV
What would this statement have meant to John's listeners? What would have come to their minds as they considered baptism with water? with the Holy Spirit and fire?

The Archaelogical Study Bible that I read has a short article entitled "Baptism in the Ancient World." It connects the idea of baptism to some of the temple rituals given by God through Moses to his people at Mt. Sinai. Water was an integral part of much that the people of Israel had to do in order to remain holy, a people separated from others. So many things made them "unclean" and therefore unfit to go to the tabernacle or temple or celebrate feasts like Passover.
When someone became "unclean" (having sex, women having their period, touching something dead other than an offering, etc.) they used water as part of the ritual to become clean again.

The "sea" that Solomon built for purification rites outside the sanctuary door of the temple was 11,500 gallons, the size of a backyard swimming pool (see first photo)! There were also ten basins on stands, each holding 250 gallons--enough water in each for a large kiddie's wading pool (as demonstrated in the second photo).
That's a lot of water! Presumably the priests would get right inside the "sea" to wash before entering the sanctuary of the temple. Otherwise, why have it so large?
A number of Jewish ritual baths, or miqvaot (singular miqveh**), have been excavated in Jerusalem, Jericho and elsewhere. By rabbinical law these had to hold at least 60 gallons (227 l) of water and be deep enough to completely immerse the body.

Therefore, it seems to me that in John the Baptist's day, baptism by water would be seen as a spiritual cleansing from all that separated them from interacting with God. It wasn't a one-time thing but something done as often as needed to ritually cleanse one's self from impurity.

What would they have understood, then, when John mentioned baptism in or by the Spirit and fire? Did they imagine themselves moving through a bonfire? Did it raise a spectre of times past when the people of Israel followed the pagan customs and "passed" their children through the fire? Did they assume it would kill and destroy them?

What was their view of the Spirit? I'm no scholar and the answer to this question seems a little more difficult to ascertain. In John 1:33b, the Baptist quotes what was told to him: "The man on whom you see the Spirit come down and remain is he who will baptize with the Holy Spirit." Who or what did they understand the Spirit to be?

The word "ruwach" used 375 in the NASB Old Testament can be translated in many ways, according to the one Hebrew lexicon I checked. Specifically, when referring to the Holy Spirit (because it doesn't always), the following apply:
Spirit of God, the third person of the triune God, the Holy Spirit, coequal, coeternal with the Father and the Son:
  • as inspiring ecstatic state of prophecy
  • as impelling prophet to utter instruction or warning
  • imparting warlike energy and executive and administrative power
  • as endowing men with various gifts
  • as energy of life
  • as manifest in the Shekinah glory
  • never referred to as a depersonalised force
Two of these grab me. I think of the Shekinah glory that led the Children of Israel through the wilderness, that shone over the ark of the covenant and that made Moses' face so brilliant he had to wear a veil for the sake of the people around him. Is this what would happen to those baptised by the Spirit? (Remember, I'm trying to think from a first-century, pre-Pentecost Jewish viewpoint.)

I think about King Saul who was overcome by the Holy Spirit so that he was uttering prophecies along with the prophets. This happened numerous times in the Old Testament to more than just King Saul. Did they imagine that those baptised in the Holy Spirit would tear off their clothes and run around like madmen speaking out whatever God told them?

Perhaps there's a third possibility. Since the people held John the Baptist in high esteem and even wondered if he was the Messiah, it would seem natural for those listening to him that day about the one who would baptise with the Holy Spirit and with fire to think (correctly) that John was describing the Messiah. They expected the Messiah to be a warrior, so did they think that baptism in the Holy Spirit would impart "warlike energy and executive and administrative power"?

As I consider each possibility, the last seems most probable because it fits their expectations. The Messiah would impart this special power to the ones he chose and then lead all those so empowered to overcome the Romans and establish a free and eternal kingdom in Palestine. [Please remember that I'm simply puzzling this through as a non-scholar without any help except what's been noted here. I could be way off track.]
"I baptize you with water. But one more powerful than I will come.... He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and with fire."
Could they have understood this to mean, "I'm facilitating personal spiritual purity but soon there will be one who will help cleanse the entire nation and country, not just the people in it"? I think they might have. Obviously, that's not what was meant at all and it's not what happened, either.

How do the two kinds of baptism relate to each other now? In that day, baptism with/in water meant immersing the whole body--like having a bath without the soap or going for a swim (did the priests in Solomon's day and beyond goof around in the water of the "sea" when theywent in it?). Water is physical but the Spirit is not. Baptism in the Holy Spirit: could it be that, as water temporarily washed away spiritual uncleanness, immersion in the Spirit would permanently destroy the spiritual uncleanness of those so baptised? I don't know. It's something I need to ponder more. What are your thoughts?

*"Baptism in the Ancient World." NIV Archaelogical Study Bible (Zondervan) p.1562.
Large pool: Dimensions: 12 feet by 33 feet / Capacity: 11,500 gallons / Depth: 3 feet, 6 inches to 5 feet
Small pool: 10'x 6', sides are 2' high


Popular posts from this blog

Monogamous, Homosexual Unions--My Position and the Story behind it

I've been asked to be one of two participants at church each representing opposing views on the matter of monogamous, homosexual unions, moderated by the pastor.  In preparation, I have written the following.  In the comments, please do not post any vitriol--from either side. If I think any comment is hateful, I will delete it. Respectful disagreement or questions are welcome, however.

My Position and Values:
I believe that sexual relations between two people of the same sex is contrary to God’s will.I would like to say otherwise but I find nothing in Scripture that allows me to do so.BEING homosexual, having a longing or desire for someone of the same sex, is not condemned in the Bible.  We all have desires that are contrary to God’s will.  The sin occurs when we feed those desires, like Jesus talks about when he calls lust adultery (Matthew 5:28).Much cruelty to LGBTQ people has happened because of the stance of the Church. We have not acted with love, compassion and listening ear…

In My Prayer Room

Oh God
You surround me with your love,
with memories
of who you are
of what you've done
of promises you've made
of who I want to be
of who I am because of you.

You give me hope and joy,
peace and gratitude.
You convict me
and teach me
encourage me
and remind me
of what it means to follow you.

You listen to my prayers
and grant my requests
in your time.
You give me insight
and knowledge
and words to write
to share your presence
your goodness
your love
your admonition
with others.

You expand my love
to pray for friend and foe
near and far
family and stranger
people as pins on maps
clustered and scattered
who know you and reject you
for those in need
and those too full to need.

You draw me close
and then release me
to bring you close to others
to serve
and love
and give
all I have received.

You fill my heart with joy
that warms
and glows
and bursts
into laughter,
and even dance.

You wrap me in your arms
and tell me
"You are mine"
with intensity that burns
and smoul…

Circle of the Musk Ox

Message by Nathan Riegeras interpreted by Debbie Haughland Chan
It was at an elders’ meeting several years ago that someone received a picture of the musk ox circle.When danger approaches, the musk oxen form a circle, enclosing the weak and vulnerable and face outwards as a solid wall of protection.Nothing but a mouse can get past the power of their horns.Society today gathers around the beautiful and successful, paying homage to those who’ve had the lucky breaks.But what would it be like if, instead of the “best” in the centre and the weaker, less successful crowding around them, the weak and vulnerable were in the centre with the strong and confident encircling them—not in obeisance but as a strong wall, facing away from the centre in solidarity against those on the outside who would destroy?Loneliness.Abandonment.These are places of terror for those living on the fringes of society but what if, as a church, we lived as the musk ox?Not long after the elders’ meeting, the church held …